It’s a mom’s job to know where her kids are and what they are up to. But is opening your child's e-mails, rifling through her room, or peeking into her journals an acceptable approach to staying on top of her activities? Circle of Moms member Loureen K. wants to know where the line is: “How much privacy should parents give their teens, and when is it appropriate to snoop?” she asks.
With so much of kids' lives unfolding online and through mobile phones, parents can feel clueless about what’s really going on. But parents also have access to new tools — not only web filters and tracking software like SocialShield, but GPS — that allow us to follow our kids' every move. Are we turning into bigger sneaks than we’d care to admit? Here, a breakdown of all the different places parents commonly snoop, from their kids' Internet browsers to their backpacks, plus Circle of Moms members' views on whether each type of parental spying is ever okay.
Yes: It's a Safety Issue
If your gut tells you that your teen or tween is viewing banned sites or receiving inappropriate messages, a show of hands among Circle of Moms members says you should monitor their online activity. "My kids are my responsibility, and so is their behavior,” says Shawn L. “There is absolutely NO electronic privacy in our household. I guess I look at it this way: If my kids did something inappropriate, and I found out about it later, I'd be appalled. I'd be embarrassed, and most of all, I'd be extremely upset. I have all of their passwords, and regularly check their online activity, Facebook pages, etc."
Nikki S. agrees, adding, “As far as Internet use goes, I will check everything that they do on the computer for their own safety. I will be upfront about restrictions and conditions of Internet and phone usage. There won’t be any "snooping" because they will know it is going to happen.”
No: Kids Who are Trusted Become More Trustworthy
Other Circle of Moms members believe that tweens and teens need to know their parents trust them in order to make good decisions. They say that monitoring their Internet usage violates not only this trust, but also privacy: “I don't agree with parents invading their child's privacy at all, ever," says Emma. “That includes demanding access to their Facebook and MySpace [accounts], and [being] friends with them on Facebook. If they're allowed to use these things then they should have their privacy respected. Just because your kid doesn't want you to read everything they say to friends doesn't mean they're up to no good.”
Checking Cell Phones and Logs
Yes: It's a Parent's Job to Monitor
In a world of cyber bullying, sexting, and child predators, it's important for moms to monitor their tweens' and teens' cell phone usage, some Circle of Moms advise. “It is my job as a mother to know. It is my husband's job as a father to know,” says Melodie. “We have 2 boys, 10 and 12. If either one of us think something is going on that shouldn't be then we are going to snoop. I check my son's cell phone all the time. My kids are well aware of that and as long as they are going to live in my house and enjoy all the things our hard earned money provides them, then I can snoop whenever I feel like it.”
Angel M. says she monitors her teen’s mobile phone activity because, “How else are you to protect them from cyber bullying, sexting, and child predators?"
No: Kids Deserve Some Privacy and Respect
Many Circle of Moms members share an opinion voiced by Nicole M. who says: "Until your child gives you a reason to be suspicious, and by that I mean more valid than hanging out with a "lost soul" and not telling you all her secrets anymore, they deserve their privacy and respect.” She adds: “If they break that trust, (and for me it would take more than one little 'Hey Mom, I'm going over to A's house to study' when you know well and good they are going out to the movies with Boy B), then all bets are off. I just think, if you show them respect, they will grow and learn to respect you (and others) more too.”
Yes: It's So Reassuring
Some Circle of Moms are so intent on monitoring their kids that they've installed a computer chip in their teen's car or are using their teen's cell phone GPS to track its owner's whereabouts. "We have one on my son's car and love it,” says Shea J. “You can have alerts sent to your phone that let you know where he is, how fast he is going. To actually track his movement you have to go online and log in. It works great.”
Patty H. says she feels GPS tracking isn’t snooping. "My philosophy is you have to trust but verify," she explains. "This way I won't have to worry about him; I can look online and see exactly where he is."
No: Leave Tracking to the Police
Other Circle of Moms members feel that getting instant updates on the speed your teen is driving or where he is in the car is taking it too far and is disrespectful. It’s not a good way to help build their self-confidence and show them you trust them, say moms like Jodi. She believes that parents should at least start “by having a talk" and giving your kids a chance to share where they are and what they are doing.
Bedrooms, Backpacks and Journals
Yes: It’s a Parent’s Duty to Snoop
Going through your child's personal belongings periodically is just part of what a responsible parent does, say some Circle of Moms members. “I agree that it's okay to go through your kids’ stuff,” says Lisa W. “If I find something inappropriate I find some roundabout way to bring it up to her and see if she'll open up about it. By no means do I say, oh, I was in your room snooping and found this or that. You have to protect your kids.”
Kim B., who checks her daughter's backpack, room, cell phone, e-mail and Facebook periodically, maintains that as long as a child is living under her roof, she "basically has no freedom."
No: You Will Lose Your Child's Trust
Other Circle of Moms feel strongly that children should have a safe place for their private thoughts and feelings and that reading journals and rifling through rooms is an invasion of privacy. “I don't snoop,” says Tara K. "I have a 14-year-old son. If I were concerned about him or anything he was doing, I would talk to him. And if I felt he was being dishonest, I would let him know that I can find out the truth, be it through his friends, their parents, the computer, snooping in his room, etc. He knows I have the power to do all those things, but I have never had to. Snooping under any but the most extreme cases is wrong. My mom read my diary once; I didn't talk to her for a month. She had no reason, no right and I was appalled that she would be so disrespectful of my privacy. She felt awful and admitted to just being curious. Not okay in my book.”
Do you spy on your kids?
Image Source: kellyxrene via Flickr/Creative Commons
The views expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily represent the views of, and should not be attributed to, POPSUGAR.