Are Apple's long-clever Get a Mac ads no longer clever? They've tried to respond to Microsoft's Laptop Hunters ads via their Hodgman-and-Long two-man show, but the results just feel a little stale. The first attempt was kind of funny, but this one, starring Seinfeld's Patrick Warburton as a slimy PC salesman, just feels stale.
Watch the ad and let me know: has Apple lost its touch with these Mac vs. PC ads? Should it embark on a new concept, or is this ad the latest in a long line of witty commercials?

Principles
I thought he was a better looking PC not a PC salesman, am I wrong?
1I definately would have gone with a PC...Patrick Warburton just sealed the deal! C(=
Plus...if more people had macs, there would be more viruses! =D
2Exactly like you said. Been-there-done-that.
3When the "I'm a Mac, I'm a PC" ads first launched, they were fresh and innovative. Now they're a joke.
Part of it, is that Apple doesn't have a good comeback for the PC hunter ads. In a recession, price is the biggest issue, and these ads seem like they're just trying to distract us from that instead of dealing with it.
Also, the ads are starting to sound like, "they get viruses," is their comeback to everything. Time to come up with another reason for people to spend a bunch more money, because this one has definitely stopped hitting home.
4the commericials are pretty bad now.
5oops *commercials
6http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jumping_the_shark
Stale? maybe... but they haven't gotten absurd.
And I love the Tick so that particular ad gave me a warm fuzzy feeling.
7They never were witty, just douchy.
I immediately dislike anyone or anything who advertises by knocking their competitors. Same goes for election campaigns. It's pretty sad if you have to resort to that, instead of just letting your positive attributes speak for themselves.
8These jumped the shark a few years ago. Time to put this concept on the shelf and move on.
9Jumped the shark? more like whale I've been a PC user for years and never had a virus and I agree with one of the posters if viruses is the only thing apple can throw at us for buying there product then maybe they should rethink there ads and maybe.....I don't know.....lower there prices to make them more competitive. Not everyone is into Macs
10"Apple doesn't have a good comeback for the PC hunter ads."
Except that Macs work better and last way longer.
This ad wasn't as clever as some of the others, though.
11PS I was surprised not to see a post about Snow Leopard being released yesterday! I just installed it on my iMac. Everything is running faster and it freed up 18 gigs on my hard drive. Sweet.
12snore.
13This run of ads has never taught me anything that makes the mac trump the pc other than the lack of virus' it has.
I'm not saying macs suck - I've got one- but these ads are starting to get just a leeetle bit repetitive.
First let me say - I have loved the commercials until this one. It is Lame! But before that they were cute. (maybe I just think the Mac guy is cute?)
14I am a PC - BUT if MAC lowered their prices I would get one. Last year my PC finally died completely after 4 years of heavy use and a bouncing trip across my patio (how if lasted that long after that horrible incident I don't know). I decided I was going to get a Mac this time around - but I had a firm budget and I could not find even one Mac Laptop within my budget so I got another PC. It's a shame that they do not make the Mac's more accessible to the masses who are on a budget.
This would be a good post, only it makes it sound a lot like the Mac vs. PC commercials came out after the Laptop Hunter campaign. Mac vs. PC commercials came out first; in fact, it's the entire reason Microsoft came out with their confusing Bill Gates/Jerry Seinfeld commercials and their Laptop Hunter commercials (fun fact: it might seem like the Laptop commercials use people who aren't paid actors, but, uh... they don't.) As for the freshness, I don't see why it's not a good idea to keep touting that PC's can contract dozens more viruses or that Macs run simple and innovative software. In fact, that's the entire reason I trashed my PC for my sleek new iMac.
15what can I say... I own both platforms and completely agree with the mac commercials.
16Windows is just a really bad imitation of the mac operation system & I'd scrap it if I had the choice.
I've had a few Macs and a few PCs and, hands down, the PCs have been better. I had countless problems with not one, but two MACs in a row. And they certainly didn't last longer than my PC; I had a PC for 8 years; it was actually still running well, I just wanted to upgrade/update.
And Anon #15, I think Geek knows that these ads were out first. But, Apple made some specific ads (within this campaign) to combat the PC ads.
17I'm sure there's anecdotal evidence for either side. My experience has been that Apple laptops last five years plus, whereas most PC laptops have a life of two or three years. (In general. I'm sure there are people with older PC laptops and Macs that had some huge issue out of the box, some things like hard drive failure are just random.) There's more of a range of quality for PCs since there are more manufacturers and the software and hardware are made by different companies.
18Yeah, I've heard of a lot of people who have had bad experiences with Dells. I've usually had HPs (and a random Tangent) and have never had one stop working; I've always just eventually wanted to update.
19I've had issues with Dells, Gateways, Toshibas, IBMs, and eMachines. Though I think my eMachine originally only cost, like $400 for the whole desktop setup, so you get what you pay for I suppose.
We've had four Macs in our household. Two have had no issues. I just had the hard drive fail in my laptop, but hard drive failures are basically random and can happen out of the box or ten years later, and Time Machine plus a Time Capsule makes everything automatically backed up all the time. And I just took it to the Apple Store, a nice and attractive young man diagnosed the problem, replaced my hard drive, and I was on my way in an hour.
The other one is my four year old iBook, and the only issue it's had was when I put bad RAM in it. Oh, and I broke one of the tabs that pulls the keyboard off.
I think I shared this in another thread but when I bought a cord to play videos from my computer on my tv, the guy at the store was warning me I'd have to change all these settings and fiddle with stuff. And of course I plugged it in and it just worked. Like my digital cameras have all just worked, and my printers, external hard drives, etc.
Anyways, I am rambling. I'm a fangirl.
20I just want to jump in with a tangent... absolutely love my vaios.
21Interesting. What do you love about them?
22Well I've had two vaio laptops and both were very powerful, gave me little to no problems and the only reason I got a new one was because I broke the screen (oops) on the first one. I like the look of it (I feel they are sleeker than most pcs) and I also like that they come standard with much more (e.g., the graphics cards, processor, etc.). Also, I'm kind of a Sony fanatic, so that might have a little to do with it.
23If it's not too bold, were they pricey? Somehow I have it in my head that Vaios are.
I definitely like that my computers look sleek. But mostly I like how if I think something should work, it usually does. Like, if I drag a picture into the icon of my photo editor, it launches the editor and opens that picture. The drag and drop power alone still kind of blows me away.
24It's turned into "how many ways can Apple say the same thing over and over again".
25They were cool in the beginning, and pointed out various ways that they felt Macs were superior, but the most recent ones have been harping on the same topics. If they've run out of ways to make Macs innovative, then they're in trouble.
Pricey compared to a, say, HP, yes. But not ridiculous. Plus, I'm of the thinking that you get what you pay for. I can't remember what I paid for my first one (more than 1K), and then the second one I got free because I had a replacement plan.
26With PCs, price really does affect quality. Even my latest HP was $1200 or $1300, but it has a huge HD screen, a fast processor, etc.
27Flip that around, I guess. Quality affects price.
28Yes. Definitely! But I do think it's nice that if someone wanted a computer and didn't have a grand to spend, they can get that easily (especially with netbooks now), but they might not get the frills of a vaio or a mac, but they will get a working computer.
29I definitely agree, sy!
30"I immediately dislike anyone or anything who advertises by knocking their competitors. Same goes for election campaigns. It's pretty sad if you have to resort to that, instead of just letting your positive attributes speak for themselves."
Tool alert.
Let me guess, you're using a PC; made by Microsoft; who's CEO is eternal Mac-basher Steve Ballmer.
Microsoft employs precisely the same tactics, and guess what: Their products don't live up to the grandiose facade they play onto it, while 9 out of 10 instances, an Apple computer does precisely what it's said to do. Brilliant.
Apple boasts of its products' greatness. What company would pretend otherwise? In contrast to Microsoft, which also naturally boasts itself, Apple lives up to its name.
31Since Family Guy, I find it weird to hear Patrick's voice coming from anyone not in a wheelchair.
32I think both have their place. We have both in our house. I've been a Mac girl for a long time but a PC user for longer time before that. PC has its advantages like lower price, more accessibility to supporting programs and games etc. Mac is the only thing I'd trust with my designing software and files.
33And I say this out of experience. The little ad agency I used to work with earlier used PCs and they would crash all the time. No problems when running the office applications though.
Post New Comment
Please share your opinion with our community, but make sure it is on topic and follows our Community Rules. We moderate comments and prohibit personal attacks, threats, spam, lewd images, or the promotion of your personal website.