Before you dismiss this post because you're "past the Spin the Bottle" age, hear me out.
You have a bunch of friends over and you decide to play some games. Rather than using the old-school method of drawing straws or rolling a dice, you can use this free Spin the Bottle app [1] to decide which player is up next. You can even adjust the speed and direction of the bottle.
And who knows, maybe after a few Grey Goose Martinis, you'll feel a bit more spontaneous and find yourself pulling a Joey and Pacey in the center of the room.