The iPhone commercial is better, simple and effective. The Blackberry Storm commercial is too cluttered and takes too long to cover what the Storm does. I find myself paying more attention to the song than the features.

I agree - there's too much crap on the Blackberry commercial

I couldn't have said it better myself, vitisva.

I like a commercial with catchy music cause I'm such an audiophile, but I really like the simplicity of the iphone ad more. I think that the graphics and slogans and whatnot are better in the Storm add, but it's just too... I dunno. There's too much of it. And it's a m inute longer than the iphone commercial. I like my commercials short and sweet, thank you.

I think the blackberry commercial is really good. The thing that give the iPhone commercial and edge for me is back when it aired there were no other phones that did what it did (in such an elegant fashion). It really was a jaw dropper.

the iPhone commercial is almost an instruction video vs. the blackberry vid just showing off what it's "capable" of doing. I prefer seeing how easy it is to use, rather than being assaulted by an onslaught of images of what it does.

iPhone

I'm really good at tuning out commercials, there's no way the Blackberry commercial would get my attention. The iPhone ads always do because the spoken soundtrack pulls my focus up to the TV and away from my computer or whatever it is I'm doing while I watch TV. I can ignore peppy music all day, but human voices are really difficult to not listen to.

I like the iPhone commercial better. It shows exactly how one would use it. After the blackberry commercial I'm left wondering if it actually is a phone I could use.

Maybe I'm biased, but I like the iPhone one a lot better.

I actually talk about the same topic but compare the iPhone commercials with the latest Microsoft commercials on my blog:
http://thehopkinsonreport.com/2008/10/02/episode-24-ad-campaign-showdown...

It's amazing how much the commercials are matching up with real-world applications in my life.

Expandable memory has my attention. And not much else.

I wonder if its camera and/or GPS works better than the iphone. They should sell that point harder if it does.

It's good there's constantly more competition for the iphone. That'll force all these phones to get better and better at lower and lower prices.

Definitely the iPhone commercial. Simplicity is the key. I tend to tune out long and cluttered commercials.

I like the iPhone ad better: simple, effective, short, and I like the music better actually. And I always love how in the end the iPhone exits with a phone call.
However, after seeing the Blackberry commercial, I definitely want one! I have an iPhone and I think it lacks a lot of things. Too bad the Storm is not a GSM phone .