Quantcast
 

Who Wins: Microsoft's Seinfeld Ads or Apple's Mac vs. PC Ads?

Mon, 09/15/2008 - 8:02am by geeksugar
3,397 Views - 27 comments

Though the second Microsoft ad featuring Jerry Seinfeld is a lot funnier than the first, I can't help but feel that it's still lacking . . . direction? Humor? As a die-hard Seinfeld fan, I'm disappointed that these spots aren't as "Jerry" as his humor on the show was, and even more disappointed because I don't really know what Microsoft is trying to say.

Contrast that with their rival Apple, who've spun the Get a Mac ad campaign off the notion that Mac users are cool and PC users are, well, John Hodgman, and I have to call Apple as the winner again. I get the point, they don't meander, and they entertain me.

Now putting aside your preference for Apple or Microsoft, tell me, which ads do you like more?

View Photos: Jerry Seinfeld
on Yahoo!

Related Geek Stories

Related Network Stories


 
 
 

27 Comments Add a Comment

  • sundaygreen's picture
    sundaygreen
    1

    Well evidently the Apple ads are better because they have a clear message, whereas everyone across the interwebs is umming and aaahing about the microsoft ads - as they don't really know what they mean.

    I get what Microsoft is saying, by putting Gates and Seinfeld in these situations of trying to get back in touch with reality - they're admitting their mistakes (vista) and probably takings steps to ensure it won't happen again.

    Jerry quips, "Why Bill? because as we discussed, you and I, we're a little out of it. You're living in some kind of moon house hovering over seattle like the mothership and I've got so many cars I get stuck in my own traffic. We need to connect with real people."

    Bill is awesome, I'd vote for Microsoft on him alone.

    16 weeks 4 days ago Report Comment
  • EvilDorkGirl's picture
    EvilDorkGirl
    2

    Um... if you're trying to sell a product, you might try MENTIONING THE PRODUCT. Or at least show a pic of it.

    I think the ad execs behind the new Microsoft ads were trying to be too witty and strange, in order to generate a buzz. I guess the buzz is generated, but I'm not about to buy anything Microsoft puts out.

    16 weeks 4 days ago Report Comment
  • Foxy Frazee's picture
    Foxy Frazee
    3

    Well at this moment there's really no comparison the Mac ads are better and Microsoft currently has two running with Gates and Seinfeld I'll hold off until they have a few more under there belt before I'll make that call, plus my favorite Mac commercial is the one where PC guy is in a pizza box trying to lure college students with a delicious pizza lol.

    16 weeks 4 days ago Report Comment
  • macgirl's picture
    macgirl
    4

    The microsoft ads are so confusing. I keep thinking that there is some hidden meaning in them. I am beginning to think that's not the case and I agree that the advertising guys were just trying too hard.

    16 weeks 4 days ago Report Comment
  • verily's picture
    verily
    6

    The Microsoft ads are cute and funny, but they have never get to the point and have no clear message. Is this supposed to make me like Windows more? Because if so, I'm not getting it from the ad.

    16 weeks 4 days ago Report Comment
  • calamari's picture
    calamari
    9

    I think it's still too early to call the race. But Apple's got nothing to worry about so far.

    16 weeks 4 days ago Report Comment
  • GoingLikeSixty's picture
    GoingLikeSixty
    10

    Since the Apple ads focus on product and benefits and the Seinfeld ads focus on nothing.

    It is Mac vs. PC everyday.

    Do 18-25 people still care about Seinfeld?

    OTOH: Bill Gates is a Prick

    16 weeks 4 days ago Report Comment
  • LittleRedRyan's picture
    LittleRedRyan
    11

    I'm over the mac guy PC guy ads. The joke has just gone on a bit too long. Plus as a PC user getting called short-old-bald-fat and lame makes me really dislike the PC V Mac guy ads.

    16 weeks 4 days ago Report Comment
  • wickedcupofjoe's picture
    wickedcupofjoe
    12

    I vote Mac ads -- only because I love Justin Long and can NOT stand Jerry Seinfeld. Plus, the microsoft commercials are dumb.

    16 weeks 3 days ago Report Comment
  • shafiii's picture
    shafiii
    14

    i'm solely a microsoft user, but the apple commercials can not be beat. the microsoft commercials are just confusing and long annoying.

    16 weeks 3 days ago Report Comment
  • BostonChick's picture
    BostonChick
    15

    Neither. The apple commercials bug me and the microsoft ones don't make any sense.

    16 weeks 3 days ago Report Comment
  • the wingheart's picture
    the wingheart
    16

    Haha, yeah. The too-cool-for-school attitude the Mac dude cops really annoys my dad. Personally, I prefer the directness of the Mac ads.

    16 weeks 3 days ago Report Comment
  • MissMarisol's picture
    MissMarisol
    17

    Apple FTW! Microsoft = Fail!

    I don't get the point of the Microsoft ads. I don't find them funny or memorable.

    16 weeks 3 days ago Report Comment
  • macgirl's picture
    macgirl
    18

    For the record I love the PC guy in those ads. I am currently loving that he banishes Mac and that he has disguised himself- "I'm a delicious pizza" Eye-wink

    16 weeks 3 days ago Report Comment
  • julibul's picture
    julibul
    19

    I think as more ads come out, the message will come together in a clearer way for a normal audience (as in, those who view the commercial as it is and do not try to find the meanings). That being said, there's a whole lot of metaphor and personification in these ads.

    16 weeks 3 days ago Report Comment
  • CocoChic's picture
    CocoChic
    20

    The Apple ads actually make me want to watch them when I see a new one. That says a lot.

    and yes, Bill Gates is a huge prick. Pirates of Silicon Valley anyone?

    16 weeks 3 days ago Report Comment
  • leeluvfashion's picture
    leeluvfashion
    21

    Apple wins in my book once again. The Microsoft ads are pointless. I like Jerry (dislike Bill after the decision to still sell Vista even though they all knew it was cr*p) and I was hoping the ads would be funny (aka classic Seinfeld humor) however it lacked so much (mostly sense.) I love the Apple guy; witty and the ads make a point.

    16 weeks 3 days ago Report Comment
  • Jyramiah's picture
    Jyramiah
    23

    This is an easy one. I hate Seinfeld. The whole show was a waste of time. Frasier was better, I don't care what you say. But I think the Mac commercials were funnier. Even though I would take a PC over an Apple any day.

    16 weeks 2 days ago Report Comment
  • Mina Xue's picture
    Mina Xue
    24

    Gotta love the MacvPC ads. Sorry, even though I know it totally stereotyping PCs (and I AM a PC), its so funny.

    And Mac just a hottie Smiling

    15 weeks 4 days ago Report Comment
  • winrob's picture
    winrob
    25

    PC ads are weird. Mac ads are funny. However I still have a PC.

    11 weeks 4 days ago Report Comment
  • gabichou26's picture
    gabichou26
    26

    The Mac ads are just hilarious. On the other hand, the Microsoft ads are confusing and weird. The Mac ones are a little annoying in principle, but they're just FUNNY. And they work.

    7 weeks 3 hours ago Report Comment
  • IndiaOcean's picture
    IndiaOcean
    27

    I htought Jerry and Bill were funny. They were witty and did not play down to your inteligence. I miss seeing them.

    6 weeks 43 min ago Report Comment

Leave a Comment

To post comments, please log in or register.



Morsels of goodness, delivered daily.

Enter your email below: